(Originally published Mar/Apr 2018)
Changing Ocean, Changing Planet
By Capt. Tred Barta
When you have spent 45 years in bluewater fishing all over the world the way I have, you’re very reluctant to accept change and to look at new facts. You’re reluctant because what you have learned so far has brought you great success. But the world is changing, the ocean is warming, the climate unequivocally is going through a warming stage and with it brings some staggering new facts that affect all bluewater fishermen.
I have caught 16 swordfish on top in the Northeast canyons, making me one of the most successful surface daytime swordfishermen in the world. I spent the last three years learning the craft of the deep drop daytime swordfishing and have garnered quite a bit of success as I have been taught by the best and the brightest. All that being said, over the last six months a number of very rare catches have taken place, all between depths of 900 to 1,800 feet mostly by daytime deep-drop swordfishermen. Some of these new catches are so mind-boggling and defy reason at almost every level I think it will make marine biology take a brand-new look at migration patterns, filling gaps and holes that had been previously not answered in the current research on bluewater species. Pay attention everyone because after you read what I’ve written it just might open the door for more success, using our time more wisely in the canyons, whether it be on a day trip or an overnighter.
Last November Capt. Austin Enzor on the vessel Primary Search fishing out of Ocean City, Maryland, caught a opah fish weighing 105 pounds. The opah usually is found in tropical waters, especially on the West Coast; it is fairly prevalent in Hawaii. The opah is an incredible fish; it is warm-blooded, one of the first ever warm-blooded fish found anywhere in the world. So I ask you, what was an opahfish doing at 1,600 feet off Ocean City, Maryland? Good question, no answers. If that’s not enough, two weeks later Austin caught a second opah fish, this one weighing 159 pounds.
Recently several blue marlin have been caught at depths from 1,600 to 1,900 feet while surface day swordfishing. Well everyone, what is the blue marlin doing down that deep? Did you know they eat at that depth? Because I didn’t, watch out and pay attention.
While fishing in Islamorada, Florida, this winter, Capt. Stanczyk aboard the Broad-Minded caught a 210-pound bigeye tuna at about 1,700 feet down. If that were not enough to question what depth bigeye tuna feed and or migrate think about the fact that several day-drop swordfishermen caught blackfin tuna and bonito. OK, let’s do this again: did you realize that blackfin tuna, bigeye tuna, and bonito ate, migrated or were even capable of being at this depth? Did you? Because I never knew.
There have been many giant tuna caught at depths from 1,600 to 1,800 feet; I did not realize that bluefin tuna were capable of going to those depths. The big question is do they migrate at these depths, or how often do they go to these depths?
A recent study done in North Carolina tagged several giant tuna caught at depths between 60 to 85 feet during the winter. After releasing the fish with satellite tags almost all fish showed a propensity to travel farther offshore after feeding and to find a warmer water so that they could digest their food. The fish lazily swam in the warmer water until it was time to feed again, and then almost all bluefin moved inshore to shallower cold water to find bait. This is a fact that very few fishermen suspected and is new science.
One might say that global warming is teaching many species of bluewater fish to adapt; others might say that since more people are fishing deep as daytime deep-drop swordfishing is becoming more popular, more unusual catches are being recorded. Some have said the use of fluorocarbon line is producing bites from species that wouldn’t normally take a bait, others might argue that the use of strobes and underwater lights capable of operating at 2,000 feet or deeper is attracting fish that normally we would not catch. Personally I think all of this is hogwash. What I think is we have not even scratched the surface in our knowledge of the pelagic species.
Let me give you an example worth a lot of deep thought:
Broadbill swordfish used to be very prevalent on top in the early spring and midsummer along the Northeast canyons as well as the 30- and 40-fathom line. Today it is a rarity in the Northeast to see a broadbill swordfish sunning on top. Swordfish used to spend time on the surface not to feed but to warm up in the morning and afternoon sun. National Marine Fisheries Service concluded the rarity of these fish seen on top as a sign the fishery was depleted; the truth be known the fishery has come back to a very healthy number but the surface temperature of the water has risen enough with global warming that we no longer see them on top; again an example of bluewater fish making changes in their feeding migration patterns right before our eyes.
The net effect is we are making legislation on our fish stocks based on false science.
Maybe, just maybe, if daytime tuna and billfish trolling is slow by midmorning to early afternoon, all canyon fishermen should be deep dropping, maybe slow trolling in the doldrums using planers and downriggers could possibly add more bites.
You may draw any conclusion you want from this article, but one conclusion that this old fox is leaning toward is if you want to be a top gun, if you want to be a great fisherman, not just a good fisherman, all of us better start looking at some of these anomalies. Food for thought.
Never give up. Never say never.
Til next tide,
Tred’n Water
Capt. Tred Barta





![furuno safety 468x60[61]](https://biggamefishingjournal.com/wp-content/uploads/Furuno-Safety-468x6061-2.gif)






